In 1516, Duke Wilhelm IV decreed that beer can have only four ingredients: barley, hops, water, and yeast. This regulation, Reinheitsgebot, persists to this day in Germany. The absence of regulations follows the dictum of caveat emptor, the principle that the buyer is solely responsible for ensuring the quality and suitability of goods to be purchased.
If you are buying apples or oranges, it isn’t all that difficult to tell just what you are buying, but in an increasingly complex society with the range of foods and especially drugs, it isn’t so easy. For decades preceding the turn of the twentieth century, the government struggled with protecting us from harm. The Pure Food and Drug Act was passed in 1906 and with it was the creation of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA.)
About this time agriculture was shifting from subsistence farming to larger corporate operations. Increasingly, processing of foods made them less easily identifiable as pure. The muckraking novel “The Jungle” by Upton Sinclair was published in 1905. The novel highlighted the exploitative and unsanitary conditions in the meatpacking industry.
Since that time our food and drug supply have become much safer due to a myriad of regulations by the FDA and the Agriculture Department. Drugs must pass rigorous testing for purity and efficacy and the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) has been charged with among other things inspecting the meatpacking industry. But with regulations come costs. The fact that meat from infected carcasses doesn’t end up at the grocery store or toxic and carcinogenic molds don’t contaminate peanuts are the result of regulations.
Ronald Regan once famously said let business be business, implying that regulations were stifling commerce. This began the legitimization of deregulations to streamline government involvement in business. The Trump has carried this torch onward. Warning letters, a key tool to keep dangerous drugs or tainted food off the market have fallen by one-third since Trump took office. The rarer but more strict injunctions have also dropped by close to thirty percent.
Deregulation in the meatpacking industry includes allowing faster processing of carcasses and a reduction of the number of USDA inspectors. In some plants, the USDA inspectors have been replaced entirely by plant employees. Do you really think that a meatpacker whose business is to profit from packing meat will view an infected or contaminated carcass with the same critical eye as an inspector paid by the USDA?
The deregulatory zeal goes far beyond food and drugs. The laws and regulations which protect our air and water are under assault. Overturning the Obama era Clean Power Plan means there will be more Mercury in our water, and more Ozone in our air just to name two.
Other actions include allowing greater occupational exposure to toxic substances, and an increase in allowed “accidental release” of toxic materials. Regulations protect us from harm. Business may not like them, and they may cause a small increase in the costs of goods and services but overall they make our society safer. It’s called civilization.
Dr. Bob Allen is Emeritus Professor of Chemistry, Arkansas Tech University.